Sinn Féin Louth TD Gerry Adams, speaking during this evening’s Fianna Fáil Private Members Debate on the Shane O’Farrell case called on the government to establish a Public Inquiry into the case and to take steps to ensure that the DPP is made more accountable for the inexplicable decisions it takes, including in relation to the O’Farrell case.
Gerry Adams said:
“The death of Shane O’Farrell on August 2nd 2011 was a devastating blow to the O’Farrell family. So too has been the catalogue of incompetence, and the appalling decisions made by An Garda Síochána, the DPP and the Justice system which allowed Zigimantas Gradzuiska to be free to kill Shane and then leave this state.
I want to extend my solidarity to the O’Farrell family, particularly Lucia, for their courage and persistence in seeking justice. Like other citizens who suffer an injustice they’ve had to take on the entire state.
Sinn Féin has put down an amendment to the Fianna Fáil motion seeking the establishment of a Public Inquiry. We think that a Public Inquiry is best placed to get all of the facts. I would therefore appeal to Fianna Fáil to accept our amendment and join with us in seeking the best outcome for the O’Farrell family”.
The Louth TD specifically raised the role and accountability of the DPP. Teachta Adams said
“The constant refrain of the government is that the DPP is independent and that it has sole responsibility to decide when and if charges are brought in any given case. But the DPP’s role in the Shane O’Farrell case raises significant concerns about its competence.
In addition, we know that in the case of Crevan Mackin, who shot and killed Garda Tony Golden, that a decision was taken by the DPP not to charge him with offences that he had admitted, including the possession of weapons and explosives.
One of these weapons was almost certainly responsible for the murder of Garda Golden and the grievous wounding of Siobhán Philips.
And then there are the serious questions arising from the DPP’s decision to prosecute people over the incident at Jobstown, involving former Tánaiste Joan Burton.
A Áire there has to be an oversight body which can hold the DPP to account for the inexplicable decisions it takes.
In November 2016 the then Taoiseach Enda Kenny met the O’Farrell family and told them he would ask the Attorney General, and I quote, to “request the Law Reform Commission President Mr. Justice John Quirke to examine how we can reform the law to provide enhanced public understanding for significant decisions made whilst fully preserving the independence of the Director of public Prosecutions.”.
Nothing more was heard of this proposal. I have written to the Minister on this matter. But so far without a reply. Although I have learned prompt and clear replies from this Minister are rare.
Can the Minister clarify the status of the former Taoiseach’s request to the Law Reform Commissioner?
Was the request ever made?
Did the Law Reform Commission President ever agree to undertake this work?
The DPP has to be accountable for its decisions. The government has a responsibility to ensure that this happens”.